I have a question. I see that Beavers, Cubs and Scouts are now allowing girls to join but in another thread Girl Guides/Sparks/etc is being advertised as well. There is no mention of boys being offered to join these groups. Is it really the case that Scouts is now coed while Girl Guides is still exclusively girls? Is there a group exclusively for boys anymore?
It’s always been my understanding that these two groups ran parallel to one another, Boy Scouts for boys and Girl Guides for girls. In fairness, perhaps they should both change and become Scouts and Guides. Both are great organizations but sometimes this political correctness and gender equality can be a little too much.
Until 1971, no Scouts Canada programs were officially co-ed (though co-ed Scouting existed here and there unofficially, mostly in small towns and rural areas). In 1971, Scouts Canada officially allowed Rover Scout Crews (ages 18-26) to become co-ed, at a Crew’s option. In 1984, this local option was extended to Venturer Scout Companies (ages 14-17). In 1992, local option was opened to the rest of Scouts Canada’s sections; Beavers (5-7) , Wolf Cubs (8-10), and Scouts (11-14). This change was intended to be an evolutionary step towards a fully co-ed Scouts Canada. Surveys within Scouting in the late 1980s showed strong interest in such a future.
On November 21,1998 Scouts Canada’s National Council passed a resolution which removed the local option and requires all Scouts Canada sections to be co-ed, unless they are partnered with a religious denomination which prohibits a co-ed youth program on religious grounds. Very few groups fall into this category, and these are usually ‘closed units,’ like those sponsored by the LDS.
Girl Guides of Canada has remained an organization for girls and women throughout the 101 years in Canada. We believe there is a place for an organization for girls only, regardless of being though of as politically incorrect.
I like that there’s still Guiding for just females. And I feel bad for boys that cannot have an organization of their own. I understand there are different opinions and reasons WHY scouts is female inclusive, and some of them are super valid reasons, but I still disagree.
I went through the ranks of Beavers, Cubs and Scouts…and the whole time i can remeber one or two female leaders. BUT there was an olde timer …MRS GREENE who was a scouting guru received numerous baiden powell awards for her contribution to Scouting over 5 decades…
i remember her clearly…a tough old broad,., who wouldnt accept an ounce of disrespect from any child around. I cant still remember her pulling on a shit rats hear for acting out.
Probably taught that kid alot of respect…i was taught respect just by her presence…
gone are the good old days of boy “jamborees”…[/quote]
I agree that we live in an equality based world which is why I’m kind of surprised that one group has become coed while the other is gender exclusive. There’s so much emphasis on being fair to one group and the other is not being given the same consideration.